Is Netflix’s Missing Dead or Alive, Real or Fake, or Staged? Reddit Update!

Netflix’s Missing Dead or Alive is real, based on actual events, and not staged. Some Reddit users claim that the series contains several scenes that appear to be fake or scripted since the production team is so determined to make it stand out from other shows. Let’s talk about facts.

There’s no doubt that thousands of people go missing every single day in the United States, yet many of them are frequently discovered alive and well because of the tireless efforts of local investigators. Thus, it should come as no surprise that each such official report is greeted with a mixture of optimism and apprehension, leading to in-depth investigations that shed light on both what happened and why. ‘Missing Dead or Alive?’ on Netflix provides excellent proof of this.

The most recent piece of true-crime Netflix programming, Missing Dead or Alive premiered on May 10 and offers something unique. There are still many iconic scenes that have come to define the genre, such as soaring drone shots and unexpected plot twists. Missing Dead or Alive, on the other hand, follows a specific law enforcement squad in action rather than delving deeply into one case (and painstakingly researching a single culprit, along with their motivations, background, and victims).

The police officers appear to be carrying out their responsibilities in a unique manner compared to other characters in similar shows. Every scene has a musical score, there are numerous camera angles, and if the police discover a charred cell phone, we are present when it occurs. Many viewers start to wonder if Missing Dead or Alive is real or fake, or if it is staged because of the unnecessarily dramatic tone. So let’s get into detail.

Previously, we touched on David Mark Taylor and Tynesha Brooks.

Netflix’s Missing Dead or Alive Is Real and Not Staged, as It Is Based on Actual Events; Some Reddit Thoughts!

Although the true crime series Missing Dead or Alive is based on actual events, there are times when it seems staged or produced since the production team is so determined to make it stand out from other shows. Additionally, the show takes its time developing the personalities of the cops involved in the incidents. Let’s examine it in detail and narrow our attention.

The four episodes of Missing Dead or Alive are conveniently divided into four different cases, using a framework that mimics being a fly on the wall while these detectives strive to solve crimes. Vicki Rains and J.P. Smith, the two main investigators, are followed as they look for clues, interrogate important witnesses, comb through audio and video evidence, and physically investigate locations.

Netflix's Missing Dead or Alive is based on actual events and is not staged.Netflix’s Missing Dead or Alive is based on actual events and is not staged.
Source: Netflix Life

The program does occasionally resemble a cable TV crime drama, with a couple of sequences, in particular, coming across as contrived. What are the chances that the main investigators provide positive news to a family and a video team is present to record their joy? Similar to this, a few exchanges between detectives come out as forced, particularly after a particularly difficult case where the outcome is less than favorable and Vicki is reaffirmed as a capable investigator. These kinds of incidents give the impression that this has been dramatized more than it should be.

Beyond those criticisms, the program does a pretty good job of demonstrating how these detectives work, including the arduous task of digging through each person’s past and background information. As Vicki Rains herself says at one point, you end up growing attached to these people and want to find them.

Even posts about Vicki Rains, one of the series’ key investigators, can be found on the Richland County Sheriff’s Department Facebook page, proving that she is a real officer employed by a legitimate agency in South Carolina. We currently have no cause to suspect Missing Dead or Alive is a fake. Some Reddit users claim that the series contains several scenes that appear to be fake or scripted. Perhaps the director had planned something more suited for the characters to say in a retake because a scene didn’t work the first time. Although I have no real knowledge of the show’s production and there may be many unscripted natural reactions.

According to our understanding, Missing Dead or Alive is real and not staged. It focuses on the Columbia, South Carolina, Richland County Sheriff’s Department Missing Persons Unit. All of Netflix’s coverage of Missing Dead or Alive has revealed that the true crime docuseries is as authentic as it claims to be.

Some Reddit users claim that the series appears to be fake.Some Reddit users claim that the series appears to be fake.
Source: Irish Mirror

Even though the topics are so depressing, we can see how some viewers would think this show is fake after watching it. It can be disconcerting how readily the camera crew appears to have access to the interactions that take place, including several angles inside a scene. Sometimes the line delivery comes off as too dramatic or badly done, and the music is also distracting.